In class today we worked on a Kohlberg moral dilemma based on a scenario comparing two thefts, one outright and one by taking advantage of an old man's generosity. I also presented my experience with two unpaid loans, one to a blue-collar worker who said his wife was sick, one to a former student who needed help.
Several stimulating questions and comments surfaced:
If people steal all the time, is it OK?
What is the difference between stealing a candy bar and stealing $1000?
I will be away next Thursday (February 2). Your assignment as a class is to respond personally to the premise that you presented: It is human nature to do as little work as possible and to get as much as possible. Do you agree that it is human nature? Is that how you feel relative to your schoolwork? Is that how you feel relative to your college aspirations? Is that how you feel relative to your future life?
What elements create "human nature"? -- our genetic make-up, family values, personal experience, societal values? Would the question be answered differently based on socio-economic status, national origin?
Your first task is to appoint a leader of the discussion (the leader should also take attendance and report it to Mrs. Simon). Have the discussion, come to conclusions and assign the responsibility for writing it up and handing it in to me on Tuesday February 7. We'll talk about it in class on February 9.